<<CARMIGOS
Back to Car Buying Advice

Choosing Between a Dealer and a Private Seller

There are pros and cons to both. Learn the differences — and how to stay protected whichever route you go.

Modern car dealership with blue Audi sedan parked outside at dusk
💡 Quick Guide: Dealers offer more legal protection and warranties but at higher prices. Private sellers offer better deals but with minimal legal protection. Your choice depends on your budget, car knowledge, and risk tolerance.

Types of Dealers

  • Franchised Dealers – Official brand dealerships (e.g., BMW, Ford). Highest prices but best protection.
  • Independent Dealers – Sell multiple brands. Mid-range prices with some legal protection.
  • Car Supermarkets – Large selection, fixed pricing, minimal haggling.
  • Online Retailers – Cazoo, Cinch, etc. Fixed prices with home delivery and return periods.

Buying from a Dealer

Pros

  • Often includes a short warranty (3-12 months)
  • More legal protection under Consumer Rights Act (see our legal rights guide)
  • Professionally inspected and prepared
  • Finance options available on-site
  • Part-exchange possible for your current car
  • Recourse if something goes wrong

Cons

  • Higher prices (typically £500-£2,000 more than private)
  • Less room to negotiate
  • Potential pressure sales tactics
  • May push unnecessary add-ons and warranties

Buying from a Private Seller

Pros

  • Lower prices
  • Can negotiate more freely
  • No sales pressure or upselling
  • May meet the actual owner who knows the car's history
  • Potential for better deals on rare or enthusiast cars

Cons

  • No warranty ("sold as seen")
  • Less legal recourse if things go wrong
  • Must do your own checks (HPI, service history)
  • No financing options directly available
  • Higher risk of scams or hidden problems
  • No returns or cooling-off period
⚠️ Watch Out: When buying privately, always view the car at the seller's home address (which should match the V5C logbook) and never hand over cash before seeing and test driving the car.

Which is Right for You?

Consider a dealer if:

  • You value peace of mind over getting the lowest price
  • You want warranty coverage
  • You need financing options
  • You have a car to part-exchange
  • You're not confident in checking a car's condition

Consider a private seller if:

  • Getting the best price is your priority
  • You're knowledgeable about cars or have a mechanic to help
  • You're willing to arrange your own financing
  • You're comfortable with the higher risk/reward balance
  • You're looking for a rare or enthusiast vehicle

Safety Tips for Private Purchases

  • Always meet in daylight in a public place
  • Take someone with you
  • Verify the seller's identity matches the V5C logbook
  • Check the car's VIN matches all documentation
  • Get a vehicle history check (HPI) before buying
  • Consider a pre-purchase inspection by a professional
  • Never pay cash deposits without seeing the car
  • Use bank transfer for payment, not cash for expensive purchases

What Next?

Now that you know where to buy from, learn about protecting your purchase:

👉 Understanding Used Car Warranties